How and when can overqualified newcomers improve growth needs-supplies fit? The mediating role of feedback seeking and the moderating role of person-organization fit
Abstract
Drawing on a sensemaking perspective, we propose that newcomers who perceive themselves as overqualified may actively seek feedback to make sense of the dissonance between their qualifications and the demands of their new role. This process of feedback seeking helps them reframe their understanding of their capabilities and the opportunities available to them, which in turn allows them to better align their growth needs with the resources provided by the organization. We argue that perceived person-organization (P-O) fit is a key factor in how this sensemaking process unfolds. Specifically, we suggest that when newcomers perceive a high level of P-O fit, they are more likely to seek feedback, thereby improving growth needs-supplies fit and, in turn, job performance. Conversely, when P-O fit is perceived as low, newcomers are less likely to seek feedback, resulting in lower growth needs-supplies fit and job performance. Our hypotheses were tested using a four-wave survey involving 238 newcomer-supervisor dyads over the first three months of employment. Results from a moderated mediation model provide support for our hypotheses. Deviating from the conventional focus on task modifications (e.g., job crafting), this study highlights feedback seeking as a proactive strategy that helps overqualified newcomers adapt to their work environment.
Room 801, 8/F, Cheng Yu Tung Building, CUHK Business School
Prof Chia-Huei Wu
Professor
King’s College London
United Kingdom