More, but Less Original: How AI Support Affects the Dimensions of Human Creativity
We study how AI support affects human creativity. In particular, we draw on Torrance’s creativity framework, which consists of four creativity dimensions: Fluency, flexibility, elaboration, and originality of ideas. We hypothesize that humans collaborating with AI, on average, (1) produce more ideas (fluency), (2) produce ideas that fall into more categories (flexibility), and (3) produce ideas with more detail than humans working on their own (elaboration). In contrast, we hypothesize that humans collaborating with AI (4) produce ideas that are less original than those produced by humans working on their own (originality). We test and verify our hypotheses across three online experiments with 836 participants in total. Our results suggest that giving humans access to AI increases creative dimensions related to productivity, such as the quantity, number of idea categories, and level of detail. However, we find that AI support decreases the average originality of ideas. We also find that the collaboration modality matters: using AI as an ideator leads to higher originality than using AI as an executor. We contribute to the emerging literature examining the impact of AI on human creativity.
Room 928, Cheng Yu Tung Building, CUHK Business School
Mr Sercan Demir
PhD Candidate,
University of Cologne,
Germany